Men's Baseball Jewelry

Save $ 22.50
Sterling Original Baseball Bat Cross PendantSterling Original Baseball Bat Cross Pendant
Sterling Original Baseball Bat Cross Pendant
$ 67.50 $ 90.00
Save $ 22.50
Sterling 2.0 Baseball Bat CrossSterling 2.0 Baseball Bat Cross
Sterling 2.0 Baseball Bat Cross
$ 67.50 $ 90.00
Save $ 25.00
Sterling Custom Number Baseball Bat CrossSterling Custom Number Baseball Bat Cross
Sterling Custom Number Baseball Bat Cross
From $ 75.00 $ 100.00
Save $ 11.25
Stainless Original Baseball Bat Cross PendantStainless Original Baseball Bat Cross Pendant
Stainless Original Baseball Bat Cross Pendant
$ 33.75 $ 45.00
Save $ 11.25
Stainless Custom Number Bat Cross
Stainless Custom Number Bat Cross
$ 33.75 $ 45.00
Save $ 22.50
Sterling Black Enameled Gripped Baseball Bat CrossSterling Black Enameled Gripped Baseball Bat Cross
Sterling Black Enameled Gripped Baseball Bat Cross
$ 67.50 $ 90.00
Save $ 11.25
Gold Stainless Original Baseball Bat Cross
Gold Stainless Original Baseball Bat Cross
$ 33.75 $ 45.00
Save $ 22.50
Sterling Baseball Catchers Mask Necklace
Sterling Baseball Catchers Mask Necklace
$ 67.50 $ 90.00
view all

women's baseball jewelry

Save $ 11.25
Sterling Mini Bat CrossSterling Mini Bat Cross
Sterling Mini Bat Cross
$ 33.75 $ 45.00
Sold out
Sterling Mini Baseball Catchers Mask NecklaceSterling Mini Baseball Catchers Mask Necklace
Sterling Mini Baseball Catchers Mask Necklace
$ 33.75 $ 45.00
Sold out
Sterling Mini Baseball Pendant With Dangle Cross
Sterling Mini Baseball Pendant With Dangle Cross
$ 33.75 $ 45.00
Save $ 11.25
Sterling Mini American Flag Home Plate PendantSterling Mini American Flag Home Plate Pendant
Sterling Mini American Flag Home Plate Pendant
$ 33.75 $ 45.00
Save $ 11.25
Sterling Mini Softball Script CrossSterling Mini Softball Script Cross
Sterling Mini Softball Script Cross
$ 33.75 $ 45.00
Save $ 11.25
Sterling Mini Mom Heart Baseball NecklaceSterling Mini Mom Heart Baseball Necklace
Sterling Mini Mom Heart Baseball Necklace
$ 33.75 $ 45.00
Save $ 16.25
Sterling Pink Enamel Youth Softball Bat CrossSterling Pink Enamel Youth Softball Bat Cross
Sterling Pink Enamel Youth Softball Bat Cross
$ 48.75 $ 65.00
Save $ 8.75
Stainless Mini Baseball Pendant With Dangle Cross
Stainless Mini Baseball Pendant With Dangle Cross
$ 26.25 $ 35.00
View All

Custom Number Jewelry

Save $ 8.75
Stainless Jersey NumberStainless Jersey Number
Stainless Jersey Number
$ 26.25 $ 35.00
Save $ 25.00
Sterling Custom Number Baseball Bat CrossSterling Custom Number Baseball Bat Cross
Sterling Custom Number Baseball Bat Cross
From $ 75.00 $ 100.00
Save $ 11.25
Stainless Custom Number Bat Cross
Stainless Custom Number Bat Cross
$ 33.75 $ 45.00
Save $ 25.00
Sterling Jersey NumberSterling Jersey Number
Sterling Jersey Number
$ 75.00 $ 100.00
Save $ 8.75
Gold Stainless Jersey NumberGold Stainless Jersey Number
Gold Stainless Jersey Number
$ 26.25 $ 35.00
Save $ 25.00
Sterling 2.0 Custom Number Baseball Bat Cross
Sterling 2.0 Custom Number Baseball Bat Cross
From $ 75.00 $ 100.00
Save $ 8.75
Stainless Mini Jersey NumberStainless Mini Jersey Number
Stainless Mini Jersey Number
$ 26.25 $ 35.00
Save $ 29.25
Sterling Diamond Studded Single Digit Jersey Number NecklaceSterling Diamond Studded Single Digit Jersey Number Necklace
Sterling Diamond Studded Single Digit Jersey Number Necklace
From $ 165.75 $ 195.00
view all

It all started with

a father and a son

All in faith Jewelry started as an idea between a father and a son. Together they created our founding company FiveTool Jewelry. Robert (the father and master jeweler) decided to craft his son Adam, the aspiring baseball player and business major, a piece of jewelry that combined his faith with his love for baseball. After many months hand carving wax patterns the Original Baseball Bat Cross was born. 

Our Story

Stay up-to-date

Blog posts

5 Tips for High School Volleyball Tryouts

5 Tips for High School Volleyball Tryouts

MLB MVP Candidates

MLB MVP Candidates

2022 World Series Favorites

2022 World Series Favorites

Free shipping

Free domestic shipping for purchases over $10