All In Faith Christian Jewelry
New Products
Shop our new Christian Jewelry here!
Save $ 6.25
Yellow Softball Necklace w/ Dangle Cross | Sterling Silver
Sale price$ 35.40
Regular price$ 41.65
Black Carbon Fiber Cross Necklace | Stainless Steel
Sale price$ 59.00
Save $ 5.25
Home Plate Baseball Necklace | Stainless Steel
Sale price$ 29.75
Regular price$ 35.00
2 colors available
Save $ 4.46
Heart Seams Baseball Necklace | Stainless Steel
Sale price$ 25.29
Regular price$ 29.75
2 colors available
It all started with
a father and a son
All in faith Jewelry started as an idea between a father and a son. Together they created our founding company FiveTool Jewelry. Robert (the father and master jeweler) decided to craft his son Adam, the aspiring baseball player and business major, a piece of jewelry that combined his faith with his love for baseball. After many months hand carving wax patterns the Original Baseball Bat Cross was born.
Men's Baseball Jewelry
Save $ 13.50
Original Baseball Bat Cross Necklace | Sterling Silver
Sale price$ 76.50
Regular price$ 90.00
Save $ 13.50
2.0 Baseball Bat Cross Necklace | Sterling Silver
Sale price$ 76.50
Regular price$ 90.00
Save $ 5.74
Original Baseball Bat Cross Necklace | Stainless Steel
Sale price$ 32.51
Regular price$ 38.25
Save $ 17.25
Numbered Baseball Bat Cross Necklace | Sterling Silver
Sale price$ 97.75
Regular price$ 115.00
Save $ 6.75
Numbered Baseball Bat Cross Necklace | Stainless Steel
Sale price$ 38.25
Regular price$ 45.00
Save $ 13.50
Black Grip Baseball Bat Cross Necklace | Sterling Silver
Sale price$ 76.50
Regular price$ 90.00
Save $ 5.74
Original Baseball Bat Cross Necklace | Gold Stainless Steel
Sale price$ 32.51
Regular price$ 38.25
Save $ 13.50
Baseball Catchers Mask Necklace | Sterling Silver
Sale price$ 76.50
Regular price$ 90.00
Softball Jewelry
Save $ 6.25
Yellow Softball Necklace w/ Dangle Cross | Sterling Silver
Sale price$ 35.40
Regular price$ 41.65
Save $ 4.46
Mini Softball Script Cross Necklace | Stainless Steel
Sale price$ 25.29
Regular price$ 29.75
Save $ 1.53
Power Band Softball Bracelet | Pink And White
Sale price$ 8.67
Regular price$ 10.20
Save $ 8.29
Pink Youth Softball Bat Cross Necklace | Sterling Silver
Sale price$ 46.96
Regular price$ 55.25
Save $ 5.74
Mini Softball Script Cross Necklace | Sterling Silver
Sale price$ 32.51
Regular price$ 38.25
Save $ 4.46
Softball Necklace w/ Dangle Cross | Stainless Steel
Sale price$ 25.29
Regular price$ 29.75
Save $ 5.74
Mini Pink Softball Bat Cross Necklace | Sterling Silver
Sale price$ 32.51
Regular price$ 38.25
Save $ 47.81
Softball Cross Necklace | Gold
Sale priceFrom $ 270.94
Regular price$ 318.75
Custom Number Jewelry
Jersey Number Necklace | Stainless Steel
Sale price$ 35.00
Save $ 17.25
Numbered Baseball Bat Cross Necklace | Sterling Silver
Sale price$ 97.75
Regular price$ 115.00
Save $ 6.75
Numbered Baseball Bat Cross Necklace | Stainless Steel
Sale price$ 38.25
Regular price$ 45.00
Custom Jersey Number Necklace | Sterling Silver
Sale priceFrom $ 90.00
Regular price$ 115.00
Jersey Number Necklace | Gold Stainless Steel
Sale price$ 35.00
Save $ 15.00
2.0 Custom Number Baseball Bat Cross | Sterling Silver
Sale price$ 85.00
Regular price$ 100.00
Mini Jersey Number Necklace | Stainless Steel
Sale price$ 35.00
Diamond Studded Jersey Number Necklace | Single Digit | Sterling
Sale priceFrom $ 263.00
Free shipping
Free domestic shipping for purchases over $50.
Easy Returns
Hassle free returns. We get it, sometimes you need to return an item.
Secure payment
Your payment information is processed securely and is not stored by our store.