All In Faith Christian Jewelry
New Products
Shop our new Christian Jewelry here!
Save $ 7.50
Yellow Softball Necklace w/ Dangle Cross | Sterling Silver
Sale price$ 42.50
Regular price$ 50.00
1 review
Save $ 8.75
Cheerleader Cross Necklace | Stainless Steel | Rose Gold
Sale price$ 26.25
Regular price$ 35.00
No reviews
Save $ 8.75
Stainless Steel Cross Necklace With Chain | Customizable
Sale price$ 26.25
Regular price$ 35.00
No reviews
2 colors available
Save $ 9.75
Cross Necklace w/ Chain | Stainless Steel
Sale price$ 29.25
Regular price$ 39.00
No reviews
2 colors available
Save $ 14.75
Black Carbon Fiber Cross Necklace | Stainless Steel
Sale price$ 44.25
Regular price$ 59.00
No reviews
Save $ 11.25
Cross Check Lacrosse Necklace | Stainless Steel
Sale price$ 33.75
Regular price$ 45.00
12 reviews
2 colors available
Save $ 12.25
Slap Shot Hockey Cross Necklace | Stainless Steel
Sale price$ 36.75
Regular price$ 49.00
39 reviews
2 colors available
Save $ 8.75
Home Plate Baseball Necklace | Stainless Steel
Sale price$ 26.25
Regular price$ 35.00
No reviews
2 colors available
Save $ 8.75
Heart Seams Baseball Necklace | Stainless Steel
Sale price$ 26.25
Regular price$ 35.00
No reviews
2 colors available
Save $ 200.00
12mm Iced Out Cuban Link Chain | 925 Silver & Moissanite
Sale priceFrom $ 1,555.00
Regular price$ 1,755.00
No reviews
Save $ 200.00
10mm Iced Out Cuban Link Chain | 925 Silver & Moissanite
Sale priceFrom $ 1,240.00
Regular price$ 1,440.00
No reviews
It all started with
a father and a son
All in faith Jewelry started as an idea between a father and a son. Together they created our founding company FiveTool Jewelry. Robert (the father and master jeweler) decided to craft his son Adam, the aspiring baseball player and business major, a piece of jewelry that combined his faith with his love for baseball. After many months hand carving wax patterns the Original Baseball Bat Cross was born.
Men's Baseball Jewelry
Save $ 11.25
Original Baseball Bat Cross Necklace | Stainless Steel
Sale price$ 33.75
Regular price$ 45.00
1104 reviews
Save $ 11.25
Save $ 13.50
Black Grip Baseball Bat Cross Necklace | Sterling Silver
Sale price$ 76.50
Regular price$ 90.00
158 reviews
Save $ 11.25
Original Baseball Bat Cross Necklace | Gold Stainless Steel
Sale price$ 33.75
Regular price$ 45.00
1104 reviews
Save $ 8.00
Sold out
2.0 Baseball Bat Cross Necklace | Sterling Silver
Sale price$ 76.50
Regular price$ 90.00
309 reviews
Save $ 17.25
Numbered Baseball Bat Cross Necklace | Sterling Silver
Sale price$ 97.75
Regular price$ 115.00
112 reviews
Save $ 11.25
Numbered Baseball Bat Cross Necklace | Stainless Steel
Sale price$ 33.75
Regular price$ 45.00
145 reviews
Softball Jewelry
Save $ 7.50
Yellow Softball Necklace w/ Dangle Cross | Sterling Silver
Sale price$ 42.50
Regular price$ 50.00
1 review
Save $ 8.75
Mini Softball Script Cross Necklace | Stainless Steel
Sale price$ 26.25
Regular price$ 35.00
34 reviews
Save $ 9.75
Pink Youth Softball Bat Cross Necklace | Sterling Silver
Sale price$ 55.25
Regular price$ 65.00
31 reviews
Sold out
Mini Softball Script Cross Necklace | Sterling Silver
Sale price$ 38.25
Regular price$ 45.00
34 reviews
Sold out
Sold out
Mini Pink Softball Bat Cross Necklace | Sterling Silver
Sale price$ 38.25
Regular price$ 45.00
31 reviews
Save $ 37.50
Custom Number Jewelry
Save $ 8.00
Save $ 17.25
Numbered Baseball Bat Cross Necklace | Sterling Silver
Sale price$ 97.75
Regular price$ 115.00
112 reviews
Save $ 13.50
Custom Jersey Number Necklace | Sterling Silver
Sale priceFrom $ 76.50
Regular price$ 90.00
202 reviews
Save $ 39.45
Diamond Studded Jersey Number Necklace | Single Digit | Sterling
Sale priceFrom $ 223.55
Regular price$ 263.00
4 reviews
Save $ 8.00
Save $ 11.25
Numbered Baseball Bat Cross Necklace | Stainless Steel
Sale price$ 33.75
Regular price$ 45.00
145 reviews
Save $ 15.00
2.0 Custom Number Baseball Bat Cross | Sterling Silver
Sale price$ 85.00
Regular price$ 100.00
309 reviews
Save $ 30.05
Free shipping
Free FedEx 2 Day shipping for purchases over $99. Same Day shipping if placed before noon CST during business hours.
Easy Returns
Hassle free returns. We get it, sometimes you need to return an item.
Secure payment
Your payment information is processed securely and is not stored by our store.